At the time the website was launched, we read all of
their claims regarding puppy mills, and would like to do a simple
translation of some of the information given on their website.
-
The site claims that the term
"puppy mill" is used by animal rights activists to further their agenda
and garner public support. In truth, the term is used to
differentiate between responsible dog breeders who would NEVER sell
their puppies to pet stores, never caring about the future of the puppy.
"Responsible" breeders take responsibility for the puppies they produce
and their dogs are not their "cash crop."
-
The site gives its own definition
of the puppy mill, quite simply saying that it is a breeder that doesn't
provide for the needs of their dogs. What exactly do dogs need to
survive? Food, water, and shelter from extreme conditions. As
long as these needs are met, dogs will produce puppies and puppy mills
seldom give consideration to the emotional needs of dogs.
-
The site acknowledges that
dogs are social animals, but makes no connection to the human/animal bond.
They state that dogs need other dogs, and in a puppy mill situation, that's
exactly what they get, a barn or shed crammed full of other dogs, with
little or no human contact, and most certainly no human companionship.
-
The site recognizes the need for
veterinary care, but in an ingenious stroke of the keyboard, they have
turned the veterinary needs of the breeding dogs, into an excuse for
selling sick puppies. Puppy mill dogs suffer from a variety of
illnesses that go untreated on a regular basis. They lack grooming,
nail trimming, dental care, and in many cases, they are not treated for
genetic conditions, such as mange, hernias, heart murmurs, etc.
-
The site states the puppy mills
are "criminal organizations." Is that true? Sadly, in most
cases it is not true. Puppy mills, even those regulated on state and
federal levels, need only to provide the three basic needs of survival -
food, water and shelter.
-
The site also refers to the
exercise needs of dogs. To illustrate how inhumane the exercise
requirements in federal licensed puppy mills are, we offer up this proof:
The USDA regulations require that dogs be given exercise. They
determined that in order to meet the exercise needs of dogs, a puppy
miller must provide a cage that is double the minimum standard. The
minimum standard is an equation that measures the length of the dog, and
then requires the breeder to allow SIX INCHES more cage space than the
length of the dog. Furthermore, USDA decided that two dogs in the
same cage was considered "exercise" and therefore each dog only needed
that six inches of space to meet the exercise requirement. Lastly,
for those breeders that didn't want to double the cage size, or put more
than one dog in a cage, USDA requires that they have an "exercise plan" on
file, though there is no requirement that the plan be followed, and no
way to know if a breeder is following the plan.
Puppy mills are real, they are
legal, and there are thousands of them operating within the law in this
country. NEVER buy a puppy without seeing the conditions it is raised
in, and the life the parents of that puppy must live. As the economy
continues to decline, many pet stores are using online sales tactics to
peddle their puppies and even more consumers are duped into thinking their
puppies come from humane and "reputable" sources. Uncle Bill's and
other pet stores in Indiana already have the "home field" advantage in their
state because of the lack of laws to regulate them, but Internet sales
extend their advantage even further. Consumers living in other states
where "puppy lemon laws" may exist to protect them (note, THEM, not the
adult breeding dogs that suffer in mills around the country) do not apply,
because the prevailing law in litigation is the law in the state where the
seller lives.
Even armed with the above knowledge, many people that purchase puppies from pet stores report that their
purchase was based on the fact that pet stores simply can not LIE or DECEIVE
the public. Indeed, there are several fair-business laws on the books
meant to protect consumers, but let's really look at the claims pet stores
make. Are they lies? Are they deceptions? Or do they
simply rely on the consumer's ignorance and the pet stores own
interpretation of what breeding dogs should be treated like?
They claim to visit breeders'
facilities.
Translation-- We do this so that you, the
consumer, will never know the truth. By telling you that we visit
facilities, you put your trust in us, never knowing that our criteria is
based on making money, not ensuring that dogs live humanely. We don't
like it if customers ask us if they can visit a facility, and we seldom give
the location of the breeder. Our business depends on keeping you in
the dark about the true horrors of puppy mills!
They claim breeders must provide
proper sanitation.
Translation-- Our breeders must hose down the
urine and feces that falls between the wire-bottom floors that breeding dogs
live in their entire lives.
They claim dogs must be given
adequate space.
Translation--Dogs are confined to cages that
can provide as little space as 6 inches longer and wider than the
length of the dog and 6 inches above its head. It is not required that the
dogs ever leave their cage.
They claim dogs and puppies must be
healthy.
Translation-- Dogs must be healthy enough to
produce puppies, meaning they must have a healthy uterus and at least one
testicle. Puppies need to be healthy enough to get out the door of the
store.
Breeders must "partner" with a
veterinarian.
Translation-- USDA requires a veterinarian of
record must be one file at the breeders' facilities. This nice little
clause saves our breeders tens of thousands of dollars in veterinary
expenses and most certainly any hint of animal cruelty or neglect.
When USDA passed the buck on health care to a single page document that a
paid veterinarian could sign, it eliminated any requirements that breeders
must follow to provide even the most basic of health needs for dogs.
Breeders must keep records and
practice breeding protocols.
Translation-- ...but little does the public
know that these records are never required to be passed on to them!
Furthermore, breeding "protocols" are established by common practices seen
in livestock.
Breeders must be in compliance with
the Animal Welfare Act.
Translation-- And our business thrives on our
customers knowing absolutely nothing about this 40 year old law that does
nothing to protect animals. The law, in short, gives puppy mills the
right to abuse animals!
Breeders are judged on competency,
not on the quantity.
Translation-- Just don't bother to ask us about
the competency of the dogs, or how they feel about being crammed, hundreds
to one small building, and bred repeatedly until they die!
Breeders must address situations
that arise.
Translation-- The consumer will never see
the conditions breeding dogs are kept in, so there is no risk of addressing
those situations. They will also never see all of our sales records, they'll never see the same dogs' names coming up over and over again on
different litters of puppies churned out every 6 months.
PLEASE DON'T BE FOOLED BY ONLINE PET
STORES. THEY ARE JUST A FRONT FOR PUPPY MILLS AND INDISCRIMINATE BREEDERS! |